Technical Report
Development of Systems Engineering Maturity Models and Management Tools

Report Number: SERC-2011-TR-014-1
Publication Date: 2011-01-21
Project:
System Readiness Level, System Maturity And Architecture Assessment
Principal Investigators:
Dr. Brian Sauser
Co-Principal Investigators:
Dr. Jose Ramirez-Marquez
As current United States Department of Defense (DoD) system development and
engineering activities continue to be challenged by formulation of larger and more
complex systems, DoD‘s methods, processes, and tools (MPT) for effectively and
efficiently addressing these challenges are likewise being challenged. The goal of this
research was to develop a mixed methodological approach to examine systems
development maturity. Qualitatively we intended to uncover and investigate the key
characteristics that drive the development of large scale, complex systems.
Quantitatively we used these key characteristics to formulate a collection of analytical
MPT to assist in making informed systems engineering management decisions. To
advance the state of practice of this research, all MPT developed under this task were
validated through application on designated projects. The validation effort was
designed to determine if they could be effectively implemented as a best practice across
the Department of Defense. The need for this research is precipitated by the need for
system engineering, development, and cost models that adequately incorporate the
unique aspects of system and technology insertion and integration. This was then
predicated on the following task objectives:
Leverage prior investments made in the System Readiness Level (SRL) body of
knowledge to explore the effects of technology and integration maturity on
systems engineering effort and cost;
Expand the scope and applicability of the SRL to address potential systems
engineering MPT; and
Enhance current SRL methods and tools to incorporate research-derived
insights, provide expanded functionality, and demonstrate the utility of the tools
in the context of a pilot project.
At present, the SRL is a descriptive model that characterizes the effects of technology
and integration maturity on a system engineering effort, particularly with respect to
integrating discrete functional systems into a coherent mission capability. The SRL
model, as developed by the Systems Development & Maturity Laboratory (SysDML) at
Stevens Institute of Technology, has been validated by the NAVSEA PMS 420, Littoral
Combat Ship Mission Module Program Office in collaboration with Northrop Grumman
Corporation which used it to monitor development and integration progress from a
system perspective. The SRL and supporting assessment methodology has proven itself
to be a promising mechanism for understanding the effects of technology and
integration maturity in a systems engineering context. This task extends the research to
better characterize the drivers of integration effort, and to explore application of the
SRL to broader areas of the systems engineering management, where validated models
and supporting tools are lacking.